The intense competition that has marked this season of BET’s Sunday Best was still in full effect during last night’s episode. The theme for the evening– songs that pay tribute to gospel in cinema– was rather creative and, for the most part, the contestants stepped up to the challenge. Before they got their turn to shine, however, the incomparable Karen Clark Sheard opened the show, reminding the nation why she’s one of gospel’s favorite female vocalists.
With a signature performance that only she can pull off, Karen Clark Sheard sang, squalled and riffed on “Prayed Up,” the single from her latest album, All In One. My only disappointment was that it was performed to a track instead of with the in-house band. Musical director Stanley Brown produced much of Finally Karen, so it seems it would’ve been a great musical reunion of sorts. In any case, Mrs. KCS gives 100% every time and, even with a track, her performances are electrifying and captivating.
Up next were the Sunday Best finalists. Judges for the night were Donnie McClurkin, Yolanda Adams and Tina Campbell, with Kim Burrell once again assisting as vocal coach during the finalists’ rehearsals. I was particularly excited to get some longer songs from them, now that there are fewer vocalists, but disappointed that some of the selected “gospel songs” on cinema were actually just “songs” on “gospel-tinged movies.” Womp womp…
In any case, here’s the blow-by-blow on each contestant:
Tiffany Carlin-Laird – “Joyful, Joyful”
Tiffany’s got such a stage presence and charisma– she’s mesmerizing. This was not her best performance, and it was clear, but even on her “bad” day, she was greater than most. Donnie picked up on both the fact that she tripped and that she was hoarse, but noted how professional and capable she is, despite all of that. In my opinion, she demonstrated that she was one of the best in this competition since her audition– she was consistent and never failed to show us the best of her gift.
Durward Davis - “I Believe In You and Me”
This is one of those “this isn’t a gospel song– it’s an R&B song by the Four Tops that was used in the nightclub scene of a church-based movie.” No matter… Durward’s voice is so smooth, he still drew me in. He does a great job of working a song– starting simply, then leading listeners on a journey before building and smashing us to pieces. That said, this performance was a bit forgettable to me, not because he didn’t do well, but because he didn’t do anything particularly memorable. It seems Durward doesn’t always create “a moment,” and these competition shows are all about being able to point back to those types of moments.
Martha Buries – “Will You Be There”
Another tune that wasn’t a gospel song, but became one last night. Honestly, Martha has a really great voice, but the song was tentative until halfway through, when she grabbed the mic off the mic stand. Her confidence, or lack thereof, has been a recurring topic of critique– from coach Kim Burrell to the judges. It’s all in the eyes and it is unsettling for audiences. When the audience thinks you’re not confident, it’s hard for them to get with you. I love that Tina Campbell encouraged her, explaining that she’s better than she thinks she is– incredibly true. I am excited for her to realize and own it.
Elder Goldwire McLendon - “He’s All Over Me”
Great song choice for him– we got to see him on an upbeat tune. I will say this upfront– if any other contestant forgot the second half of an entire verse, they’d be cut, regardless of how much singing and steppin’ they did for the rest of the song. That said, I think the judges are more interested in showcasing the power of God in this 79-year old contestant (and his more-than-impressive vocal ability and agility) than in nitpicking over a misstep or two. And I can’t be mad at that. Plus, to put it bluntly, this industry hasn’t really cared much about forgotten lyrics– I can pull out studio albums from the 1980′s on which our legends completely mumbled through the lyrics, pressed the song to wax anyway, and put it in stores, like “here ya go!!!” We bought ‘em and they’re “classics” to this day.
LeAndria Johnson – “Speak Lord/God Is Trying To Tell You something”
It was yet another display of LeAndria’s awesome vocal ability. This particular performance was a little more haphazard than her others, but she’s still the one to beat in this competition. She’s one of those singers to which we inherently pay close attention– always curious to see what the next line is gonna be, how she’s going to deliver the next verse, or what riff she might throw in the next time around. LeAndria snatches our attention and makes us wait for her every move. She’s a consummate professional.
Before the judges narrowed the competition from 5 to 3, songstress Lalah Hathaway took to the stage to perform one of my faaaave Phil Collins songs– “Against All Odds (Take a Look at Me Now).” From tone to delivery, Lalah Hathaway is simply unrivaled, so it’s always great to see her.
At the end of it all, only three could continue to next week– LeAndria Johnson, Elder Goldwire McLendon and Durward Davis.
Last season, I knew who my top two would be, and could even name a favorite to win. This time, not so much. In fact, as I type this, I’m realizing that Tiffany was my favorite. Shucks!
In any case, I’m inclined to say it’ll be down to LeAndria and Elder McLendon, and the public will pick LeAndria when it’s all said and done. But we’ll see…
What did you think of this week’s episode???
#teamleandria but I believe it will come down to leandria and duward.then I believe duward will win not that he's not great cause he is by far the best male Sundays Best has ever had... But due to a male being in the final 2 they will give it to him... But my God that Leandria!!! She should win not because she lost her house but the girl is BAD and there's an anointing there!
Nice recap, EJ! :-) Can you do a blog entry of gospel music in cinema for the very reasons you stated? The parameters for the song selections in this episode's roster was rather confusing. I mean, I didn't see "Free Willy" and don't plan to...but what was the (gospel) message in that movie? (Giggle!) So this is my first season watching and from what longtime viewers have been saying, it's time for SB to have a male winner...so maybe that's the reason that the final 3 looks like it does: to stack the odds for a male winner: a 2-1 ratio, yes? So if I had to pick of the 3, LeAndria takes it. She's anointed (and please understand I DO NOT throw that term around lightly), she's got grit, personality, a fearlessness that comes when you've lost everything and there's nothing (else) to lose. She's Sunday Best to me. If it's a male winner (within the music buying/downloading demographic), it's Durward. If it's a male winner who doesn't look like the music buying demographic but is a wonderful novelty, it's the gentlemanly Elder McLendon. I had not given Tiffany enough credit for her presence on this show. She is a professional and she'll do well post SB. I'm glad she did not sing another Tremaine song and I liked her selection this week. If she had not been hoarse, she would have let us have it! Martha, as pretty as she is and as nice as she seems, still didn't do it for me vocally. And I still can't put my finger on what that "isn't" is.... So of the final 3, it's been a nice ride to see them develop....
Welcome back EJ...great recap...but I beg to differ with some of your comments. As I stated last week Le Andrea needs to be more versatile ..she screams too much.This became very evident this week when she did not do well with the song since screaming was not an intrigal part of the singing....Elder on the other hand is very consistent and hands down the winner last night.(Knowing the words or not). I would vote for Elder ,Most viewers tune in just to watch Elder He IS THE STAR of the show. That's my take....
I'm sorry, I'm just going to come out & say it....Elder Goldwire's time on this show should've been a cut a couple weeks ago! Now it's clear that the judges are holding FAVORITISM above professionalism and it's not making the show enjoyable. You cannot convince me that Elder Goldwire is more vocally competent than some of the contestants sent home before him. Yes, he's anointed but so are many others. The amazement is the fact that he's 79 years old and in good health. It's hypocritical for judges to turn away so many talented people during the audition proceedings for not being "marketable" to outside church audiences. But does anyone honestly think the world is going to rush out & buy a cd from an 80 year old man? Let's get real here. This is the 2nd time Elder Goldwire has forgotten the words. If this was the conduct of ANY of the younger hopefuls - they would've been sent home! It's NOT fair. Tiffany Carlin-Lard has been consistent throughout this show...she deserved a spot in the Top 3.
I'm still a little upset that my Hebrew got cut so early, but I need leeandria to win. I can wait for the elder and D's albums, not leeandria's! Lol.
Won't comment on the contestants till I watch it...but I will say that the theme for the night was NOT COOL! They had a HORRIBLE batch of songs to pick from. It was almost impossible for them to match the greatness in last weeks episode picking from that batch of songs. Hmph...
@v4c there are way too many real gospel songs in cinema to resort to the song from Free Willy! I'm highly surprised nobody sang Oh Happy Day. If I heard that song in a movie one more time, I was gonna scream! Lol
I agree with Keisha. Goldwire should be gone. His age is playing a part in why he is there. If any of the other contestants would have forgot the words they would've been sent packing.
Are you against older people Keisha and luvtolisten? Come one, many of the gospel artists such as Shirley Casear (70), Albertina Walker (80) Joe Ligon (70) and Bobby Jones (71) are still performing in this industry. It burns me up when people want to discard older people just because they are competing with young people and thinking that they are not worth being there. What you want them to do, die in a old folks home or something and not thinking they cannot be used of God? I'ts sad when when the church and people who love gospel music want to discard our elderly because they feel that this is a "young people's business"(I'm 51) Again, why don't you look at people like Betty White, and see what I mean. And she's not a gospel artist. I'm sorry EJ, but some of the comments against Elder Goldwire burns me up because I have an elderly parent and I don't have any respect for those who think they are too old to do anything at all. God can use older people as well as younger people as well. And yes, I'm one of the ones hoping that he will be one of the finalists. And yes, it will teach the young folks a lesson that anyone can do anything, even in their elderly years.
i think duward gave the best performance last night. the other contestants are very talened too, but seem to lack versatility. versitile singers can take you there even if they are nervous, lack confidence, or are hoarse. i also feel that letting the elder slide will give him a false sense of security.
For the campaigners who want to not want the elder to be in the competition, I wish you people look at that video once again and see why he is in the competition. And again, she and Leandria will be the top two people on there.
@Gayle No offense but Bobby Jones, Shirley Caesar, & the other elderly people you speak of are LEGENDS. They have been in the gospel industry for more than 30 years. They are NOT on talent competitions trying to generate a career at this age. So, in no way, are they comparable to Elder Goldwire McClendon. No one is saying that Elder McClendon is too old to be used by God or have a place in ministry. We're not saying that he should go off & die in a nursing home. Please don't over embellish what is being said! This is a competition show & if you are not up to par...you should be sent home. Young or old. Elder McClendon just has not exemplified the best talent and has not been consistent in presentation.
Keisha, anyone can accomplish something at any age. Look at the people in the bible just because they are advanced in years, God did not forget them. Hannah had a child when she was older and others were used by God as well. Sorry, but some of those people with the exception of Durward and Leandra on that show neither does not exemplified the best talent as well neither. So we have to agree to disagree.
About the gentlemanly Elder: He's a modern-day Caleb...and it's a beautiful thing to see. And yes, forgetting the lyrics to a song is a requirement, regardless of the "anointing" in a singing competition. And usually it's a reason for rejection. But because this is a show that requires viewership to justify ad prices, the Elder gets to stay. Maybe, just maybe, those other (rejected) contestants should take a lesson from the Elder by coming up with a novelty, gimmick, if you will, to make one more noticeable, popular, memorable. In this case, the Elder's "novelty" is his age yet he's not doing anything to make it happen. He just is, which makes his longevity on the show all that much sweeter. Even though many of the rejected voices were good and genuine, they were not MEMORABLE. And in (gospel) cough>entertainment<cough, marketability matters. --Hebrew Boy: too out of reach for the (general) gospel music audience. --Bow Tie Boy: nice, clean-cut young man: faded into the background. -Dreadlocked brother: looks/sounds to much like Jonathan Butler...been there, done that. --Mr. Mohawk: needs more time to figure out his style. --Big Fro'ed Sis: two previous winners look and sound like her. Get the drift?
@TamTam....You are so correct...It's all about the marketing/business aspect of the show.Viewers will always remember The Elder (In a good way)just like in the auditions they remember Peter.."He Tossh Me."He stood out.On You Tube over 90,000 viewers have viewed Peter's audition.
"And yes, forgetting the lyrics to a song is a requirement" *I meant to say REMEMBERING the lyrics....* :-)
I agree w/ Tam Tam, especially about the "entertainment/marketability" factor. I believe that Leandria & Durward will be the top 2. I do love Elder Goldwire's performance & voice, but I don't think he'll stay in these last few weeks...at the same time, I'm not a judge on Sunday Best so obviously my opinions don't really matter lol :) I'll just continue watching & hopefully the show will make a turn for the better, which I think it will.
First I'm so sad to say I missed the KCS performance and the Tiffany performance so I have to view the episode when BET posts it :-(. I saw the others and I thought Elder would be cut but I'm not surprised that he is still in. I always wait to see what LeAndria is going to do and although not my favorite performance she's still my top pick. I feel it should b down to her and Durward. I thought she would perform a soft performance as well but not yet. I can't believe Tiffany is cut but its down to the nitty gritty now! :-)...so soon too!
I admit, I do anticipate Elder's performance as well and Donnie's reaction! :-)
Stop it Keisha M.!!!
I'm sorry but Durward Davis is a bad mama jamma! And the cool thing is he ain't sweet like past contestants this brotha is all brotha with a great voice! He's my pick to win it! I don't think leandra brought it like she did last week and what can anyone else say about the elder? He's bad! and yeah he forgot the words or did he? Or was it the annointing and he was speaking in tounges and we just thought he forgot? Hmmmmm If double D. don't win, it will be a travesty! Pray for the people of the gulf coast~~~~!!!!
"and yeah he forgot the words or did he? Or was it the annointing and he was speaking in tounges and we just thought he forgot? Hmmmmm" LMBO...nice try, LOL Finally watched! Tiffany did not bring it. There was nothing grand about it. Lauryn Hill played with the same notes for her lead and made it a HIT! So, I'm with Tina on this one. I think I was more annoyed that Martha was trying to make "Will You Be There" about God, lol. IMO, it just took something away from the lyrical point of the song. I dunno. She sang pretty...but I just didn't feel it...or get it. LeAndria was due for an okay night, lol. She can have one...ONE, lol. She sounded nice but she was no Tata Vega. She was incomparable...in a "not so good" kinda way. She didn't seem comfortable and it looked and sounded like she was just making it work. After weeks of dag near needing a sheet after she sings, I'm not trying to hear her "make it work"! I want her to take me to the throne room! But she gets a pass cause she's been so stellar. And I'm also beginning to notice that I don't like the way she doesn't finish some of her words (Jazmine Sullivan annoys me with that too...). I think this performance showed other weaknesses as well...but I won't nitpick. ;-) Now, don't get me wrong...I'm all for the rules. But this is a GOSPEL competition...not AI. So, the HOLY GHOST can and WILL change the rules! Can I get a witness?! *quickened* So, yeah, Elder forgot the words. But, at 79, do you think you'll be able to memorize even a new phone number in a week? Good luck with that, lol. The pace of the show must be overwhelming for him and he's done a fab job keeping up in my book. He had me in the beginning of the song, lost me for the verse, I said a lil'prayer (I'm sure Donnie did too, lol), he brought me back at the chorus again, sang that verse like a pro, then he just took off...never looking defeated! Man, God is just with him. So, welcome to the final 3, Elder! I praise and worship God every time you hit that stage... If this was the finale, Durward would have the crown. He didn't Jesusify (pronounced Geez-us-if-i) the song, lol. By the time he was done, I believed I was his dream come true...and I know he wasn't talking to me, lol. I totally felt Yolanda's comment cause he made me wanna praise God on behalf of the woman he was singing to, lol. Which means he performed one of those miracles he said he believed in! He SANG SANG SANG it like a pro! IMO, he really has been the most consistent...showing all sides of his voice. Durward is my choice to win.
EJ, This was a great recap! Karen was great, but I would have enjoyed her more with the band as well. Lalah left me speechless. As for the contest I am all for Team LeAndria as well, but as for Mr. Davis, this was his most notable performance yet. For me, I think his consistency is most memorable- I can count back to every song and remember the same journey or "walk down" to the climax. He is an amazing psalmist, and I think he is going to give Ms. Johnson a run for her money. Elder Goldwire is my heart- in my opinion he has already won. I'm not sure that he will be able keep up next week as this week proved he's being pushed to learn the material quickly like everyone else. As Kim said last night "this is still a competition." My thoughts for the last two standing- Mr. Davis and Ms. Johnson. I wouldn't be surprised if the next SB was male either. We will see!
Double Q (quick question): Does anyone have any comments about the background vocals on SB this year?
My pick is Elder Goldwire McClendon... I believe he has made all of the contestants reach down within... Leandria relized that when Elder Got a standing ovaition on the first show. Thruth be told Elder Goldwire McClendon has touched millions of people from the beginning. He has touched all age. It bothers me as well when the younger generation don't want to reccognize Elder McClendon. But in my opinion its a sign of the time... It could also be that those who have made comments about Elder don't have a male image in their life to look up to.... I believe every judge on the panel wouldl ike some of the anointing that Elder Goldwire has. As a Magazine Editor and Program Director I see & hear a lot of music but Elder Goldwire has been singing 70 years and I believe each artist should have spent as much time with him for his knowledge and wisdom... Many shoud take the time and do their research Elder Goldwire is a member and has been with a label for years. I believe for him it was loyalty to the group he started with and is still with to this day. I haven't bgeen a big fan of Sunday's Best But this season I can't wait to see what Elder is going to wear and sing... I see him being the WINNER of Sunday's Best!
Durward Davis is a musical BEAST!!!! All the rest can go on to the house.
Backgrounds sound wonderful of course... just look at who they got. But um, did a few of them miss rehearsal this week? They were strugglin wit the lyrics on that Michael Jackson song! It was kinda funny. Yet they still knocked it out. professionals. Elder Goldwire: Donnie goes IN wit this dude. I think it gives him hope. But I dont get the hype. I mean, he can sing and he's old. I guess that equals anointing cause that word is thrown out a gazillion times on this show. But who REALLY is going to buy his record? (its rhetorical, you all will say that you will... but you wont) And if ANY ONE ELSE would've forgotten lyrics, it would've been a problem. He didnt sing the song THAT GREAT for it to have been overlooked. He just danced his way out of it...
I have said that if LeAndria is not in the top 2, that I would quit EVERYTHING LOL Lalah Hathaway is one of my very favorite singers. If you've been singing for a long time, you can sometimes guess what ad libs a singer is going to do and most times you're right. She throws you COMPLETELY off guard and does things that are TOTALLY different and I love it!
LeAndria did an awesome job and pick a great song that is historical to all of us. I didn't know there were so many levels to the songs. OMG!!! I strongly agree with "me". I am sorry, I think Elder is a blessed individual and he may need a album. There are no SOLO gospel men his age in the industry, so he will shake the industry. I wouldn't buy it. He is not Sunday Best and I believe Tiffany should have stayed. She was hoarsed (gave her all) and Elder mumbled and forgot the word. And yes I am aware and humbled to the anointing but STILL.
Dear saints: don't fool yourselves that folk wouldn't buy an Elder Goldwire CD. With the right combination of songs, esp. some gut-bucket hymns, sound quality, etc., it would sell. Remember that even though Bishop GE Patterson sleeps, his series of "Singing the Old Time Way" CDs are selling. I mean, I bought one! (And yeah, I grew up COGIC but still! LOL!) There IS a market for Elder's type of music. And if you (general use of "you") REALLY love gospel music, then you would make yourself recognize that there is a place for these hymns. And to go back even further, before Carlton Pearson went in "another" direction, his Azuza CDs were all hits. I got those, too! And I still pull them out when I need to hear some old-school hymns and choruses, etc. And what's up v4c! :-) LeAndria's song was not the easiest to sing so I think she should get extra points for picking a more difficult song. It had a lot of pacing changes (fast, then slow, then fast again). And Durward deserves glaze for his rendition of "I Believe In You and Me" because as he was singing it, I was thinking that that song would sound great for my wedding! I think Durward is Sunday's Best SINGER, but not Sunday's Best CONTESTANT. LeAndria is Sunday's Best contestant for reasons I stated in my first post. And a huge shout-out to Lalah Hathaway! That's how you interpret a song, Chrisette!
Everyone is always talking about the anointing this & anointing that. I get it but is Elder McClendon the only one that's been anointed? Because I don't think so. By that reasoning, I guess we could never arrive to a winner in this competition. Speaking of the anointing, won't the Holy Spirit bring all things to your remembrance? John 14:26 L.O.L. I'm just sayin'. We can't get all deep here. Someone will have to be sent home, it's not all about ageism.
S'up TAM TAM! :-) You're right...it's not an easy song. But, if it was too hard for her, she shoulda sang "Oh Happy Day", lol! The Color Purple is one of my all time favorite movies...you can't go messin wit Shug's "moment" unless you know what to do with it! I'm still with "Double D" for the crown, lol. But they'll prob release him and LeAndria on the same day anyway, LMBO! You know how they do it. So, both teams are winners in the end! LOL... And I TOTALLY agree that Lalah's cover was better than Chrisette's. I love both voices. The color and texture of Lalah's voice is just SHWUUU! I do love Chrisette but seeing Ledisi live kinda made me knock her down a few notches in the talent department, lol. When is Ledisi gonna be on Sunday Best???????? She FLOORED me with "Think of You" during her live show. The crowd almost went IN! The BGV's totally hit the mark when they came in on "I Believe in You and Me"! I was squeeling and kicking and yelling at my computer monitor! LOL! YES! And I can honestly say that I prob wouldn't buy Elder's album either (maybe a few cuts)...but I'd DEF go see him live. He'd pack out a venue...
Preach Keisha M! And let the church say....... (lol)
I missed this week's performance, however, I heard about the results. Based on my preferences, I wouldn't have picked those finalists. As for Elder McClendon, he is definitely anointed, and not only anointed, but the man can sing too! However, as several have already stated, if anyone else mixed up the words every week, they would have been sent home the first week that they messed up the words. I hope that there are particular criteria that they can say they were judging for, that they can show the previous contestants in writing, because that could cause a problem...again, not at all against Elder, but I don't think that's quite fair. As a sidebar: @ Jay "I’m sorry but Durward Davis is a bad mama jamma! And the cool thing is he ain’t sweet like past contestants this brotha is all brotha with a great voice!" Did you really just say that?? Come on...you can do better than that, especially since you're making generalizations and assumptions about people that you do not know. Wow...the saints.
I guess at the end of the day, neither Tiffany, Martha, or anyone else for that matter was gonna beat Durward or LeAndria for the final two spots. So, what difference would it really have made if they went home before Elder or not? Now, I can admit that I'm sure I'd feel differently if I was on team Tiffany or team Martha, lol...but since I'm not, Elder's third place finish is fine with me. If he makes it to the final two...I'll jump ship and join the protest! LOL...
Anointing in a singing competition? Nah.... At least I don't expect it. It's a bonus should the Holy Spirit show up. I've said it before and I'll say it again: there ought to be a shared understanding about Who the anointing is. It's more than just a squall or a bunch of emotional riffing.... The real situation is making a decision to choose a winner based on their 1) singing ability, 2) marketability or 3) because of the anointing, or 4) some combination thereof.... So among the final 3: they can all sing. They each have varying levels of marketability. They each have be anointed. So how to choose? From what I have seen of last year's winner: she can sing. She's got a marketable story. Is she anointed? Ehhhh.... Can the anointing (alone) move product? Uh ohhhhhh.... So here's the thing: the "anointing" is usually not a part of the equation that goes into choosing a winner. There I said it. Discuss.... ;-)
The people here are talking about the "anointing," the "anointing", but another thing to consider is that is that "anointing" is leading people to Christ? Just because a person has an advertising campaign and all, it does not mean that the person is an evangelist, or their words that they are singing are planting seeds for those unchurched people to come back to God. I just hope the producers and those who are competing and the judges realize that. Yes, its entertainment, but hopefully too, I just hope also that the purpose is that these contestants on the show and the voting public realize that they should not vote for the person just because they look good or they can bring whatever, but the person that best have a christian example and imitate Christ and not because of marketing--that should come second.
I'd go with #4, Tam Tam. I think it MUST be in the equation for a gospel competition...an unwritten element. If God's presence keeps showing up when a person sings, who are we to override that based on #1 & 2...or not consider it? Can the anointing alone move product? Tricky question...cause I personally see anointed and equipped as a package deal, lol. God's not gonna give you a task without giving you the proper tools to carry it out! The CD will have the anointing and good production and good lyrics and ___ (fill in the blank with everything a good gospel CD should have).
I hear/read/agree what you're saying, v4c, applied OUTSIDE of a singing COMPETITION. How can the anointing be judged in a competition? If one is anointed or not? Or HOW MUCH/HOW OFTEN one is anointed? Or the most important question: WHO is doing the anointing? Michael Jackson was anointed...but by whom? @ Gayle: my question is beyond the scope of what the anointing does. How does leading people to Christ equate to product sales? Consider the "reward" of winning the Sunday Best title: it isn't jewels in a heavenly crown. It's money, a car, and other things that can only be used on Planet Earth. Please hear me: evangelism and winning souls matters at the end of the day. But Sunday Best is a singing competition, with judges who decide who stays and who goes. My root question is this: what are the criteria for a winning contestant: singing ability, marketability, the "anointing", or some combination thereof? v4c's response is that it's all these things. I can get with that.... Who would Jesus choose? Hmmmm.... ;-)
@ Tam Tam I think the real question is, who has God already chosen. Whoever is going to win is going to win. All of this back and forth about the anointing and what not is pretty useless. Vote who you want to win when it gets down to the final two and let it be.
Good point, mylum.... Whoever wins, I'll be satisfied. I'm not that invested.... But it's been fun to watch and thus my curiosity is raised to ask questions in a friendly conversation. Although I do have my qualms about gospel competitions of any kind....
And Tam Tam, that's 90% of my beef with gospel competitions. How do we and who can judge the "anointing"? The answer: Really, nobody but Jesus! That's why I generally don't watch or go to them. Cause the way the anointing touches me and the judges always differs...and that's ok cause God meets our needs differently based on who we are individually. And even though I know that, I end up with an attitude, lol. But I was lured in by all the posts about how FAB the contestants were...as I was during the first season, lol. The point of gospel music is to draw people to Christ through music...inside or outside of a competition. The only way you can have the power to do that is to have the anointing. It's impossible to disregard the anointing in anything connected to the Christian church...at least I believe it is.
@ Tam Tam, I realize this is a singing completion and yes, prizes has to be rewarded~however, those prizes are temporary and people cannot take them to heaven with them--not trying to be judgmental or stand in judgement with people on there because people like Leandra has a story to tell, being with the clothes on her back and that's a terrible feeling when you are without things and the Elder, who seems like he cares about souls. But what I'm concerned about is that Christians in their opinions are treating this competition like the secular American Idol and hoping various people get thrown out because they don't fit what the "world" want them to be and they feel they cannot make it in the business because of their age or figure or whatever. If you ask me, all of them are winners and instead of hoping this one or that one get off, we need to congratulate them because it takes courage to get on stage~and that's all of them.
v4c, Your quote about drawing people to Christ reminds me of a quote by the Rev. James Cleveland who said, "What good is a song if it not gonna move you?" I hope and pray some of these contestants are living what they are singing about too and just not because of an experience.
Great points, v4c. You articulated them well and I agree. @ Gayle: I definitely hear what you're saying as well and I think that the Elder has earned his place (not counting the missing lyrics). Age ain't nothin' but a number. ;-) Per your second paragraph: a harsh reality check is needed. It goes back to the point about marketability. The world does have an acceptable look for its entertainers. Heck, even gospel music industry has a range of "acceptable" images. And if one doesn't fit the mode, they don't get "accepted". Tonex is one example of that (in terms of the different costumes he wore. Not that "other" stuff). What about not one but TWO gospel divas, if you will, who went through surgeries to modify their body size. We cannot deny their expanded range of attention that has come because of those changes. No longer are we in an environment where our gospel singers can be asexual and obese... unless you're male... but that's a different conversation for a different day! ;-) So I do hear your points, Gayle.... :-)
@ mylum - Since we go against what God wants on the daily, how do we know that the judges choice was God's choice for a winner versus what God allowed? LOL...unnecessarily deep, right?! So, here's to hoping God's choice and the judges choice is Durward!
*nervous grin* I pray that's a good thing, Gayle, lol.
Sorry Elder but I think your time is up. Tiffany should have stayed and I truly believe she would have won. She has wonderful range and looks fantastic.
Elder is my "Sunday Best"....That's it folks.
@v4c unnecessary deepness! I'm melting! I'm melting! Oh what a world! Lol!
@tam tam maybe i need to re watch but i was not feelin mrs hathaway and i LOVE her but i guess it was just me.. but i thought last week chrisette did an amazing job with stand her voice is acquired taste though but i loved it. i dont like the fact that donnie PREACHES after everytime elder sings its kinda bias dont you think? im not tryna take nuthin away from elder cause he is obviously god blessed but cmon this is STILL a competition and thats not fair IMO dont crucify me lol
I agree with you Michael Dixon, I didn't enjoy Lalah Hathaway at all. It was not the right song selection for her IMO. This is opening a different can of worms but I wish producers of these gospel shows strictly booked gospel artists. Promotional opportunities for gospel artists are already few & far between.
@MDixon: yes, it could be said that Donnie is playing favorites w/the good Elder...which leads me to believe that he may not win the SB title but certainly a show and fan favorite. I just heart Lalah's style so there's not much musical wrong she can do! :-) @Keisha: I do agree with you about the inclusion of "non-gospel" guests on the show. It relates to the marketability issue again, but this time, it's about the marketability of the show itself. But on the other hand, Lalah is a featured singer on Kirk Whalum's newest gospel jazz CD... so there's that connection, I suppose....
I love the honest comments and the vibrant discussion. I know Elder Goldwire and have heard him sing throughout the years, and therefore have been a bit disappointed because I've NEVER known him to forget his words before. I am also disappointed because I haven't heard Elder sing 1/4 of his capability. I don't know whether it is the presssure of competition but Elder Goldwire can SING you under a pew and out the church door. It is frustrating for those who have heard him sing before Sunday Best because we want you to hear and witness what we already know - that he is a GREAT singer and his time is long overdue. I strongly believe this is the reason why despite the misphaps of missing words that God has kept him in the competition and sent others home because it is HIS time and season. However, as one blogger stated that seeing him in the audience live during the Sunday Best performances is whole different story than what we see on tv. Based on the judges AND audience reactions, I am a believer. If you listen to the audience reactions to his performances vs. Leandria's and other contestants it does not compare. I believe he does possess the elments needed for winner. He is marketable, and captures your attention- I know many people that say they tune in JUST to see Elder Goldwire- people LOVE him and he is the most interesting and entertaining contestant of the 20 chosen. He does have great vocal ability and better control than most of the contestants. As someone said, he always creates a memorable moment. Each performance I can remember almost every move and note, whereas some of the contestants I know they were good but can't really remember what they sang or how they sung it. I like all of the contestants and think Durwood and Leandria have exceptional power and are both fantastic but Durwood is somehow still forgetable. Leandria is very memorable (though as much as some are accusing Goldwire's attraction of being his age, I do hear alot of comments that because she was homeless, she deserves to win) BUT she does scream and her vocals aren't as controlled as some of the others and the last two performances showed major weaknessess in her vocal ability. However, I love her because she can sing the phone book and make it work, and she gives it all she has. My main concern with Leandria is I get the feeling she doesn't sing in the church, or at least much. It is something about her that makes me think her cd will not be strictly gospel- at least not as we know it..It is one thing to be versatile but she just doesn't sound like a church singer in ANY of her performances. I think some confuse annointing with being inspirational and yes, she is very inspirational.
Ok let me get the singers out of the way...Durward is the man and that's my pick - I was about to go in on a secular song(Lord help-lol) He has a way of painting a picture of whatever song he sings!! Leandria is awesome but Iwant to hear her sing...I enjoy Elder and I look forward to hearing him every week, but I don't believe he'll be the winner. Ok I'm going back to whoever asked about the background singers...now no doubt they (especially Isaac LOL-love him!) messed up a little bit but being the professionals they are they came through big time! I believe most of them are Kirk's singers...they blazed!! Ok ya'll....THE BAND IS HOTTTT!!! On Joyful, Joyful I couldn't hear Tiffany because the band was incredible. Also on Lalah's song...she was great like she always is but the band took me there! And last but not least, Karen was amazing and she looked amazing too!
VYI, I agree with you. And some who are giving the Elder an unfair assumption. And also I'm incensed that many feel he should be gone and that is because again, the attitude of the church that we cast our senior saints aside and gospel music is for "Younger People" only. That is a form of ageism it you ask me. I agree that the Elder is marketable if the right people and the right record company support his career. There is a man who will be 84 years old next week by the name of Chuck Smith. Chuck Smith started the Jesus music and today, a lot of people gives him a lot of respect now because he taught the gospel and lived the gospel and this is why God allowed him to live this long to share the gospel to this day. Why don't give the elder some respect too and not garner these negative comments about him because he is forgetting the words and vice versa. Why don't we all pray for him as for all the contestants because you know what, this is turning into hate and negativity against this man just because another contestant should have sent home.
Yvi M., here's what we need you to do. We need you to find some footage of Elder...and he's got to be completely on...so that we can see and feel what you're talking bout. Get it loaded up on youtube, then let EJ know so he can post it for us. Cause I'm having a hard time imagining him being better than he's been...although I can imagine him remembering the words, lol. If there's more to him, I wanna hear it! Not on the next episode though cause I want Durward to win! LOL! j/k... And Gayle, I don't view it as negativity or disrespect as much as they are differences in opinions...and that's ok, right? We can disagree in love... Let's go, Durward, let's go! *clap, clap*
Overall, I think it was a pretty good show for what it's worth. I loved both Tiffany & Martha, they are incredible singers but for me, their performances weren't that great this time around. Durward took a classic song and delivered it like it was written yesterday. It was excellent. Leandria, was good & she held herself well through that performance. The Elder, I thought he was good as well. Lalah Hathaway, that was definitely NOT her best. I think it was more so the choice of song, cause she can sure enough sing you through the floor. I love the final three, but as for the final two...I'll just have to wait like everyone else :)
I think its going to be out of Leandria and Elder Goldwire. For those that were voted off I hope they continue and pursue music. Its no reason why they can't be successful. Alot of AI contestants that didn't win the title sure are!! I throughly enjoyed Chrisette and Lalah Hathaway. I can't compare them and wouldn't try. Truly enjoy both!! Would love for Ledisi and Fantasia to stop by. Huge fan of the vocal skills of Karen Clark Sheard but not her stylist.
The judges have to stop voting their emotions and start voting the ability of the performers. Sorry, in the end Gospel music may move people but, it is a business. Whomever does the music arrangements for the show need to go back to the drawing board. The songs seem rushed or jazzed up. How about that old time religion?
@V4C, Lol! I actually had a video from an event where he was the guest soloist. But I played it everyday and it finally ripped, but if I can get another copy and have someone convert it for me- I would definitely love all to hear his finer moments.
@ Honestly Yeah I said it b/c it's great to see a man like Durward Davis sing and has no Feminine tendencies when he sings. Yes I can say that because I call it like I see it. Yes the brotha is anointed and all man that’s all I said. Judging from last year it's just good to see that every brotha that can sing doesn’t have to act like feminine and in my opinion he doesn’t. Now focusing back to the recap I hope Double D wins! And the elder and although I like him too is a money maker anyway. It’s good to bring back the old school. Ps It’s time for a man to win this anyway!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol
I believe it will be Elder McClendon and Durward in the finals. Leandria YELLS to much for me. I give it to her she can sing. Sunday's Best will be Durward!!!!!!!!
I'm with you EJ on your pick for the final two. Elder and Leandria make you wanna tune in just to see their performances.
Durward not... did you miss the commercial with him ***EDITED BY EJ FOR LACK OF RESPECT***... you can't possibly feel anything when he sings... he is a good singer, don't get me wrong, but it is all too staged, and what's that about no wanting to practice? Anyway, the Elder is the elder... IMO I think they should just give him a contract for a couple of CDs. I do think that Donnie is biased, but he's a preacher, and can't help that. Leandria is the clear winner to me, as one blogger stated, they don't think she's a gospel singer, or that she doesn't sing in church often... I agree, but there is a meekness about her spirit, and I think each week she grows to know HIM more. Only time will tell who the winner will be... kinda wish Jessica Reedy was in this years competition... and where is her CD? shouldn't it be out by now... I disagree with the one writer... I think it is good to see the non-gospel singers share their faith... it's good to know that they believe. Both Chrisette and Lalah were wonderful, both made me cry, but the way Lalah turns a phrase... and changed the words to the song really gave it new meaning... "there no more empty space... everything around me is a reflection of your face (I think grace would have worked here too). Now if they would get Kem on for the next show, that would be great...
LOL @ yadah...your first two lines remind me of my cousin talking about Bobby Jones! I have no clue what commercial you are talking about and I may have missed the comment he made about not wanting to practice but I absolutely feel something when Durward sings...so it's possible, LOL.
Just to let you all know the impact the Elder is having.... One of my patients is always telling me that she wants to hear the old man sings.When ask about the other contestants she says they all scream too much. So there you have it for what it is worth.(LOL)
@Yadah said: "I disagree with the one writer… I think it is good to see the non-gospel singers share their faith… it’s good to know that they believe." Believe what? Believe who? Anybody can sing a "gospel" song. You don't have to be "saved, sanctified, filled with the Holy Ghost, fire-baptized" to sing a "gospel" song. I'm not saying that Chrisette and Lalah are or are not either way. What I am saying that just because you sing a gospel song doesn't mean that you are "automatically" a believer. Some folk are just real good actors. And then it depends on the so-called "gospel" song that is sung. Some so-called gospel songs are so far from THE GOSPEL that you probably don't have to be a believer to sound convincing. We really do have to be more discerning about an emotional response versus a Holy Spirit to Holy Spirit connection.
@ Tam Tam I read all your posts! If you not talking...Next!
I'm a Leandria fan, and I believe she can win this, however I feel as though although anointed, the Elder is not up for the challenge of recording, touring, and all...he is talented but Leandria really is Sunday's Best!
Just as many believe last season was fixed. I believe Durward Davis will be the winner this season!
@ Tam Tam, I agree w/ your last post...fully. @ Yadah, I do respect your opinion, but I think where some people would find your comment disagreeable is that BET is FULLY dedicated EVERYDAY to secular music, TV shows, etc. The gospel arena ONLY has their set programs on mainly sundays (which is to be expected from that particular network). There's the once a year Celebration of Gospel, Sunday Best, Bobby Jones, etc. So it wrong for some folks to at least want to see only "gospel" artists at those times? No, I don't think so. It's all well that they want to "share" with us & everybody else, but as my dearest Tam Tam :) stated above...share what? What are they sharing? No we can't judge what's in their hearts or how they feel about God, but when you research & follow their careers, you can see that some of these non-gospel artists have VERY DIFFERENT views on just who God is. And anyone can sing a gospel song or an inspirational song, but it doesn't mean that their "personal faith" is being shared. So I can see the problem that the other poster & other people have with having non-gospel artists on Sunday Best. Much love :)
Elder- Needs an award. Let him go home knowing he won sunday best in a category of his own. Durward Davis- Turned that love ballad into a gospel song! Martha Buries- is boring to me and yes her facial expressions throw me off too. LeAndria - I was doing the holy ghost dance by the end of that song! I wish they chose better songs. Father can you hear me....there are so many gospel cinema songs to chose from... the song selection was disappointing. Nikki Ross is a background singer-- did you peep her?! I love her something awful. (and since she is a good friend of Thigpen she further proves my point that he shouldn't have been on the show...no hate. Listen to Nikki Ross SANG I'm available to you while playing on the organ! @ his church. Lawd! I watched that youtube video over and over and over) *The background singers needs a collective solo.* Lalah Hathaway - love her. but umm nothing special. She sounded pitchy.
@ Everyone and everybody!! If Elder Goldwire won that would be great. I would want Double D to win but id the Elder won it would be fine. If the Elder won how many of you will go and buy his cd? I could only see him doing old school which would be great but alot of singers out there did that like Joe Pace, Mom & Pops Winans.....ect And in my opinion can't nobody sing old school like eddie cain Jr. AkA Marvin Winans... But how many of you would go out to buy his CD? Just askin....
Oh one more things BOBBY JONES can't sing for real. He's not legendary. He just has a tv show. *that is all*
Wow!! Sunday best really has folks talkin!! This episode-was not the best, probably the worst(to me) EVER! I did not enjoy-at all. Though KCS shut the place DOWN!!(To me) lalah hathaway's performance: what can you say?? Classic!! Her voice is simply breath taking(to me) I still wish the judges would start giving real critiques instead of tellin everybody "I love you, you're anointed" that's not a critique!! I still say based on people's complaints and ratings BET is payin Tina extra money to be extra nice(that's just me!!) I understood her critiques and how she said stuff, being that I myself am not one to hold my tounge. It takes more that just bein able to hit some high notes, do some riffs runs and groans to be "sunday best" or even a gospel artist at that it takes first off: HAVIN the HOLY GHOST/ANOINTING; and let's not confuse anointing with havin a good voice, cause there's plenty of people out there now who can sing they behinds off, but do not have NO anointing. Having anionting is being able to usher in the presence of god, and sometimes we get so caught up in the music and how the bgv's soundin in the background, that we lose Focus on the individual's stage presence/confidence...and I hate to sound so shallow, but you're appearance does matter. Let's be honest sanctified folks-some of us wouldn't have paid our girl and favorite leandria a bit of attention if she wouldn't have opened her mouth-based on her appearance(get outside of your 'sanctified holy ghost filled' selves and be realistic)so I want the judges to be brutally honest, because even in the gospel industry,not everyone is going to be acceptive of you, sad as it may sound, but face it: gospel music is a business when it all boils down-plain and simple.(*steps down off the soapbox*) Now, these performances: Tiffany-"joyful, joyful":she clearly had voacal struggles,but her energy level was wayyy down Martha-"will you be there"-even though it wasn't a "gospel song" it still should have been performed at a much higher level.it just didn't do it for me. She should've did some research,like watchin a then eight-month-pregnant jennifer hudson blow this song away at michael jackson's memorial Duward-"I believe in you and me"to me it was forgettable,so forgettable in fact I had to find the paper I wrote down with the song choices. The caliber should definately have been better,because it was sung by THEE whitney houston,plus it's a classic(gospel song or not) LeAndria-"speak lord/god is tryin to tell you something-again to me,not the best.you could tell she struggled,and she wans't completely comfortable with it. Elder McClendon-"he's all over me"- I laughed through this entire performance!! Honestly I did!! He came out doin jumpin jacks with his feet,forgot a whole verse and just hummed, then came back and killed the verse. What more can you say?? I loved it-pure comedy!!(To me) Sunday best/bet, I think the viewers need a do-over of this episode,cause I feel cheated!!!I don't know about anybody else, but I feel duped!! (*Sigh*) right now,this show is completely unpredictable, we all know who should win(leandria) but either duward or elder is gonna win...sunday best has officially "jumped the shark"(it's a tv thing)...
@ms.diva - "Let’s be honest sanctified folks-some of us wouldn’t have paid our girl and favorite leandria a bit of attention if she wouldn’t have opened her mouth-based on her appearance(get outside of your ’sanctified holy ghost filled’ selves and be realistic)so I want the judges to be brutally honest, because even in the gospel industry,not everyone is going to be acceptive of you, sad as it may sound, but face it: gospel music is a business when it all boils down-plain and simple" Unfortunately you're absolutely right...but when you think about the category that Leandria would probably fit into, that's the way she would be received by the younger generation, so I think that's the focus there, which I do understand. Also...(I know I'm opening a can of worms...)Tina and Yolanda sometimes makes you shake your head with what they bust out with so I don't think they could say too much about Leandria's wardrobe...I've seen them look hideous when it was appropriate to put on the 'mall clothes'...
@ Jay - "Nights like dis...I-I wish...rain drops would fa-a-a-a-aaaaall!" One of my FAVORITE movies! LMBO!
Oh yeah... @Celybelley the background singers are off the hook! We need to let them open the show with a little something before the season ends. It would also be nice for Kim to bless the saints too!
@ Saudra, your comment about the Elder not up to touring sounds like agism to me. Not all older people are not in bad health u know..
@v4c...still trying to get another video or audio of Eld Goldwire but have you seen the Thanksgiving 09 video someone uploaded on Youtube? I think it's a little closer to what we're used to hearing from him. Definitely heard better but keep in mind it was an informal family Thanksgiving dinner.
There has been some good talent that went home that should've stayed. Elder is a blessing to perform on Sunday Best. BUT Leandra, MY GOD, everytime that young lady opens her mouth it is her own testimony. That shout she did tonight is well deserved. We are to praise him through the good, bad and in advance. That is has done and is doing. Her dry days are over and the RAIN is here. Can't wait for her CD. Amythest
Elder Goldmire Elder Goldmire....You have my vote. LeAndria struggled again tonight.
I have enjoyed watching from day one. I've cried every time I've watched the show and been inspired by most of the singers. I live 60 miles from NO and have not been to a live show, but to have enjoyed every show. But I do not feel the best two people are going to be on the stage for the final round. I,m inspired by Eld Goldwire, but I did not here what I heard from the other two singer. Really, they brought tears to my eyes and inspired me to want to do more and be everything that I'm called to be. When I look at Eld Goldwire, I better understand that it is not over until God says it's over!!!
I just can't believe the way, Elder McLendon sings, but am sure that he would tell the world and all who would listen that nobody but, God gave him this wonderful gift! I'd love to drive up to, Phila. just to be in one of his church services. He truly is a Blessed man of God and while I never met this preacher, I know without a doubt that he is a true Soldier! Rev. Gene Williams Burlington, NC
pastor goldwire can sing but he does'nt have the sunday best voice that the judges say they r always looking for
Karen was hoarse, but she still tore it up.
Tiffany- Awesome, great energy, looked beautiful. Showed us that sundaybest stage is right where she belong. She was hoarse but ripped through that song like only a proffesional could. just kinda waitin on her album.... Durward- Looked sharp as always! FANTASTIC JOB! Martha- My all time contestant came out and tore this song to shreds. Again, just waitin on the album. I think if she had more confidence, and looked more happy on stage, instead of scared and nervous, she woulda have top 3 slot. Because she has an awesome voice. And a Rasp 2 Die 4! Lol, love u Martha Elder-Nice to hear him singin an upbeat tune. He defintely keeps showing us awesome versatility. I do agree that if a contestant forget the words like he did, they should be cut NO EXCUSE. But because ELDER is just that Good, u just cant be mad.